Individual stocks vs. funds: the trade-offs
There's no single right answer. Here's what each approach does well, and where it falls short.
How funds work
A mutual fund or ETF pools money from many investors to buy dozens or hundreds of investments at once. You own shares of the fund rather than the companies themselves.
- Strengths: broad diversification in a single purchase, easy to buy for small amounts, and simple to hold.
- Limitations: every fund charges an annual expense ratio, taken inside the fund. You can't remove companies you'd rather not own. And mutual funds may pass along taxable capital gains, even in a year you didn't sell anything.
How a portfolio of individual stocks works
Instead of a fund, you own shares of each company directly, in an account in your name.
- No fund expense ratios on the stocks themselves.
- Transparency. You can see exactly what you own and why.
- More control over taxes. Each position has its own cost, so gains and losses can be managed one holding at a time, for example by selling a position at a loss to offset gains elsewhere.
- Customization. A portfolio can work around a large position you already hold, or leave out companies you don't want to own.
The trade-offs
- Company-specific risk. With fewer holdings than a broad fund, a single company's trouble has a bigger effect, so the portfolio can be more volatile.
- It takes work. Each holding needs research and ongoing monitoring.
- Results can differ from the market. A stock portfolio may do better or worse than a broad index, sometimes for years.
- Smaller accounts are harder to diversify with individual stocks alone.
How we use both
For most clients, we build portfolios of individual stocks around their goals and comfort with risk, and we use mutual funds and ETFs where they fit, for example for areas that are hard to cover well with individual stocks. Read more about how we invest.
General information only, not individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Rules change and your situation may differ; check with your tax and legal professionals before acting.