PSLF vs. refinancing your student loans: how to decide

For many doctors, attorneys and other professionals, this is one of the biggest money decisions of their early career. Here's how to think it through.

How Public Service Loan Forgiveness works

PSLF forgives the remaining balance on federal Direct Loans after 120 qualifying monthly payments made while you work full-time for a qualifying employer, such as a government agency or a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, including many hospitals and universities.

  • Your payment is based on your income, not your balance. On an income-driven plan, the monthly payment is a percentage of your income, typically up to about 10% depending on the plan and your family size, and it rises as your income rises. The plans available have changed in recent years, so it's worth checking the current options for your loans.
  • 120 payments is roughly ten years, but they don't have to be consecutive. Payments made while you're at a qualifying employer count, even if you leave for a while and come back.
  • Training years can count. For many physicians, payments made during residency and fellowship at a nonprofit hospital count toward the 120.
  • Forgiven amounts under PSLF are not federally taxable.

How refinancing works

Refinancing replaces your existing loans with a new private loan, ideally at a lower interest rate. That can lower your total cost and help you pay the debt off faster.

  • Refinancing federal loans is usually a one-way door. Once federal loans become a private loan, you give up PSLF, income-driven repayment and other federal protections, such as certain deferment and discharge options.
  • Your payment is based on the balance and the rate, not your income, so it stays the same whether your income rises or falls.

The real question: your career

PSLF isn't just a loan decision; it's tied to where you work for the next decade. That's why the most important questions are about your career, not the loans:

  • Will you stay with qualifying employers for ten years or more? If there's a good chance you'll move to private practice or a for-profit company, PSLF may never pay off.
  • Does the qualifying job make sense on its own? A higher-paying role that doesn't qualify can be worth more over a career than the forgiveness itself. It's worth comparing the two paths side by side, not just the loan numbers.
  • How will your income grow? Because PSLF payments rise with your income, a big raise can change the math.
  • What if you change your mind halfway? Payments already made still count if you return to qualifying work later, but if you leave for good, PSLF won't apply. You'd keep repaying, and any forgiveness would come only through an income-driven plan's much longer timeline.

If you're married, your spouse matters too

Income-driven payments are based on your adjusted gross income, so your spouse's situation can change the numbers significantly:

  • Your spouse's income. If you file taxes jointly, most plans count your combined income, which can raise your payment.
  • Your spouse's loans. If you both have federal loans on income-driven plans, your payments may be calculated together and split between you.
  • How you file your taxes. Depending on the plan, filing separately can mean only your own income counts, which can lower your payment. But filing separately often means a higher tax bill and losing some credits, so the savings have to outweigh the extra tax. It's worth running it both ways each year, with your CPA.

Lowering your taxable income can lower your payment

Because payments are based on your adjusted gross income, pre-tax contributions to qualified accounts, such as a 401(k), 403(b) or 457(b), and to a health savings account, can lower your payment while you save for the future. On PSLF, a lower payment can also mean more of your balance is eventually forgiven. Saving as much as you comfortably can into these accounts is often one of the most effective steps, and we coordinate the details with your CPA.

Who each tends to fit

  • PSLF often fits people with large balances relative to their income who are confident they'll work for qualifying employers long term, such as many physicians in academic medicine or at nonprofit hospitals.
  • Refinancing often fits people in private practice or the private sector with a high, stable income and the goal of paying the debt off quickly.
  • Many people are somewhere in between, and that's where running the numbers matters most.

A personal decision, made case by case

There's no rule of thumb that fits everyone. The right choice depends on your loans, your income today and where it's headed, your career plans, your family and your other goals, like saving for retirement or buying a home. We look at each situation individually and compare the options side by side, including what you'd pay in total under each path.

We've been through this ourselves. We've worked through PSLF and refinancing decisions in our own family, and we're happy to run the numbers with you. Federal student loan rules change often, so we check the current rules at studentaid.gov before making a recommendation.

General information only, not individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Rules change and your situation may differ; check with your tax and legal professionals before acting.

Related

Have a question about your own situation?

Schedule a call